A 30-Year Grudge: The 1949 Harlem Springs Farmhouse Murders

A delusional perceived grudge triggers a shocking double murder and insanity trial. In the early morning hours of June 3, 1949, a terrifying double shooting shattered an isolated farm in Lee Township, near Harlem Springs in Carroll County, Ohio, sending instant shockwaves into neighboring Tuscarawas County. John Dunlap George (1909-1949), a telephone installation lineman, roseContinue reading “A 30-Year Grudge: The 1949 Harlem Springs Farmhouse Murders”

Inquest of Lunacy: The 1907 Murder of Dorothea Sindlinger

A delusional Civil War veteran claimed divine voices commanded a horrific crime. Simon Sindlinger Jr. (1841-1915) was born in Mötzingen, Württemberg, Germany on October 28, 1841. As a young child Simon Sindlinger Jr. emigrated with his parents across the Atlantic to the United States around 1847, eventually settling in Tuscarawas County, Ohio, where his fatherContinue reading “Inquest of Lunacy: The 1907 Murder of Dorothea Sindlinger”

Two Glasses of Beer and a Tragic End: Canal Dover, 1886

A dispute at a Canal Dover, Ohio saloon turned fatal when a one-armed stranger was forcibly ejected onto the pavement. William A. Ziegler (1855-1917), born to German immigrant parents Peter (1835-1919) and Genevieve Ziegler (1830-1914), grew up in Franklin Township, Tuscarawas County. Ziegler married Mary Gross (1857-1931) in November 1878, and, by 1880, the youngContinue reading “Two Glasses of Beer and a Tragic End: Canal Dover, 1886”

Bloodshed at the Brickyard: The 1921 Murder of George Andrews

A 1921 brickyard argument turned deadly, leading to a trial partially decided by a baseball legend. During the Great Migration, a period of American history when millions of black southerners moved to find work in the industrialized cities of the north, many found themselves in Tuscarawas County, Ohio. A fatal confrontation occurred at the CrownContinue reading “Bloodshed at the Brickyard: The 1921 Murder of George Andrews”

A Fatal Eviction: The 1954 Murder of Harvey Johnson

Kicked out of his apartment, a Dennison man took his rage out on the World War Two veteran who evicted him. Content warning: This post contains references to suicide. If you or someone you know has a mental illness, is struggling emotionally, or has concerns about their mental health, there are ways to get help. Click hereContinue reading “A Fatal Eviction: The 1954 Murder of Harvey Johnson”

1925-1932: The Seven-Year Hunt for the Slayer of Frank Wilson

During the Great Migration, a period of American history when millions of black southerners moved to find work in the industrialized cities of the north, many found themselves in Tuscarawas County, Ohio including Tennessee native Frank Wilson. In the early hours of November 7, 1925, Frank Wilson (1902-1925) was killed by a six-inch ax fractureContinue reading “1925-1932: The Seven-Year Hunt for the Slayer of Frank Wilson”

A Veteran’s Final Battle: The Murder of George LeMasters

New Philadelphia WWII veteran George Jasper LeMasters was tragically murdered during a robbery at a Canton hotel. George Jasper LeMasters (1906–1950), known to many as “Jap,” was born in Union Township, Tuscarawas County. His early life was marked by tragedy when his father, Ernest LeMasters (1877–1918), was killed in a mine accident when George wasContinue reading “A Veteran’s Final Battle: The Murder of George LeMasters”

A Killing on 9th Street: The 1918 Death of Albert Cordrey

A fatal 1918 lawn-mowing dispute leads to a sensational manslaughter trial and ultimate exoneration. The life of Nellie Rhodes Claycomb (1886-1934) took a dramatic turn several years after her marriage to George A. Claycomb (1890-1953) on October 21, 1913. George was originally from Oklahoma, and Nellie was a housewife who already had a daughter fromContinue reading “A Killing on 9th Street: The 1918 Death of Albert Cordrey”

Mystery on Factory Street: The 1930 Death of Gilbert Lloyd

Eight bullet holes, a fatal 1930 “accident,” and the constable who walked away entirely free. Gilbert Sunkle Lloyd (1899-1930) was a Cleveland native who established a life in Dover, Ohio, as a family man and business owner. Lloyd was a well-known local figure, operating a gas station on the 300 block of Factory Street whileContinue reading “Mystery on Factory Street: The 1930 Death of Gilbert Lloyd”

Fight of His Life: The 1915 Trial of Frank Rose

A young Italian laborer fought for his life twice; first in a Bolivar boarding house and then in a court of law. Frank Rose (1895-?), born Francesco Russo in Caronia, Italy, immigrated to the United States aboard the S.S. Italia, arriving at the Port of New York in April 1913. A laborer described as 5’4”Continue reading “Fight of His Life: The 1915 Trial of Frank Rose”